Deciding between influencers and UGC creators depends on your brand’s objectives, budget, and desired level of control over the content.

by Shannon Hinderberger

The distinction between influencers and user-generated content (UGC) creators often confuses a brand’s marketing department. Both play pivotal roles in brand promotion strategies but cater to different needs and objectives. Understanding their differences, advantages, and drawbacks is essential for brands leveraging social media for authentic engagement.

What is an Influencer?

Influencers are social media personalities who have built a substantial following by creating content that resonates with their audience. They collaborate with brands to promote products or services through gifted collaborations, paid partnerships, and brand ambassadorships. The content is primarily shared on the influencer’s platforms, although it may also be reshared by the brands involved, depending on the agreement.

Pros of Using Influencers:

  • Wide Reach and Engagement: Influencers can expose your brand to a large and engaged audience, potentially boosting visibility and engagement.
  • Trust and Credibility: Followers often trust influencers’ recommendations, making influencer endorsements a powerful marketing tool.
  • Professional Content Creation: Influencers produce high-quality, professional content that aligns with your brand’s image.

Cons of Using Influencers:

  • Cost: Collaborating with influencers, especially those with large followings, can be expensive.
  • Complex Negotiations: Agreements on content ownership and usage rights can be complicated and time-consuming.
  • Risk of Mismatch: Partnering with an influencer whose audience doesn’t align with your target market is risky.

What is a UGC Content Creator?

UGC creators are individuals who produce content featuring brands or products in niches they love. They often produce the content at a fraction of the cost or free product. This content is seen as authentic and trustworthy because it’s perceived as a genuine endorsement from a satisfied user.

Pros of Using UGC Content Creators:

  • Authenticity: UGC is perceived as more genuine and trustworthy, as real users create it without compensation.
  • Cost-Effective: UGC can be more affordable than influencer marketing, as it often relies on a much smaller content creation and sharing budget.
  • Enhanced Engagement: Authentic user stories and testimonials can drive higher engagement rates than polished influencer content.

Cons of Using UGC Creators:

  • Less Control Over Content: Brands have limited control over the quality of the video; with that being said, audiences are really into messy, unaesthetic content.
  • Scalability Challenges: compensated UGC creators typically have their posts shared directly via the brand’s channels rather than on their own personal platforms. If the creator loves the product, they can post the content if they want to.
  • Ownership and Usage Rights: When compensating UGC creators, brands must navigate content ownership and usage rights, which can be complex.

Which Should Your Brand Choose?

Deciding between influencers and UGC creators depends on your brand’s objectives, budget, and desired level of control over the content. Influencers are ideal for reaching a large audience with professionally crafted messages, whereas UGC creators offer a more authentic and cost-effective way to engage with potential customers.

If you want to explore using UGC content creators in your business, set up a call with DASH to review our UGC management options.

DASH Content Co.

Marketing, Strategy, Design, UGC and Content


115 NW Oregon Ave, #9, Bend OR 97703

Phone Number

(458) 202-0886

Business Hours

Monday - Thursday 9am - 4pm
Reach out anytime and we'll get back to you!

Sign up to get Dash Notes

Our marketing trends and tips newsletter:

Copyright © 2024
DASH Content Collective